Skip to main content
|
Back to graphical site
H
ome
A
bout Lemon
S
ervices
O
ur Work
N
ews & Comments
C
ontact Us
Lemon Foundation
Online Marketing, Production & Design.
TEL. +44 (0)20 7681 4040
Lemon Network Login
Lemon foundation » News & Comments
Monday, May 22, 2006
The trouble of recruiting good people
posted by
John Bown
Lately, we’ve been talking to many people looking to recruit either into their companies to do work within their business, or into agencies to do agency work. Back in ’99 it was cool to call yourself a web designer, then it was probably worse than flipping burgers at MacDonald’s - now it seems to be back in flavour with those in the know. But despite that return to favour, it seems to be harder recruiting good people than finding a good curry in Fulham.
There seems to be some debate as to what people are looking for – deep vertical knowledge with a particular technology or wide general skills that are useful everywhere. Most people would agree that there is no silver bullet and that if you’re looking for people to execute on a project, you’re probably going to need deep knowledge, whereas if you’re looking for management and planning / consulting skills, you’re looking for people with a wider experience, but who know what technologies to apply and where.
At the same time, there seems to be a lag in the industry (or at least in London), where corporate types are looking for people that can do the bog standard web and application work, and where a growing number of people are pushing the Web 2.0 dream – standards compliant markup, seamless user interaction, web applications instead of web brochures, owning data instead of owning eyeballs; and all underscored with the acronyms we’re all becoming more familiar with. Some are even getting entrepreneurial and realising that web based business models are possible too!
Of note, the BBC has started doing things that are very progressive (mainly due to the progressive individuals at the BBC that are making things happen), and this in turn is raising the profile of the new web and the promise it holds –
but where on earth do you find the people to help you to do these newfangled things you’re dreaming up in the company meeting room?
This is a very good question, but it seems there isn’t a straight answer. Finding good people is hard for some of the following reasons:
Good people know their value.
Because they’re veterans of the first internet boom they’re older, wiser, and less willing to work for peanuts. The fact that many of them now have families to take care may also be a factor! Because they know what value they bring to a project they’re in a better position when it comes to negotiation – you could always go for someone cheaper and with less experience, but then you never know what you’re getting yourself into.
Good people are probably already doing something they enjoy
, so it’s likely you’ll not be able to lure them away unless you’re able to offer them something significantly better than what they currently have.
Good people want to work with other good people
and it’s for this reason that companies like Google and Yahoo! are a honey pot for the brilliant people in the industry. If you can’t offer someone the company of other likeminded stimulating people, you’re unlikely to be able to attract them from wherever they are.
Good people are probably already working for one of the giants
, which is almost a culmination of the above 3 points. The giants know that in order to keep their good people they have to offer great packages within a great working environment, so you’ll probably find that at the giants good people are valued, doing something they enjoy, and working with other good people.
It’s not all doom and gloom though – it is possible to find good people, but more often than not it will come down to knowing exactly what kind of person you’re looking for in order to find that person, and then being able to trust that individual to perform as promised.
Oftentimes businesses decide that they aren’t in the business of looking after and recruiting technical people, so they decide to outsource their needs to people that do these sorts of things – and this is often the best course of action to take for many obvious reasons. That said, it’s vital that you know and trust people you outsource work to, and if the people you know can’t actually do the work for you, then it’s probably better to ask them to help you to find the skills you’re looking for as they’re more likely to be a better judge of an individuals ability than you are – just because they work in the industry.
Tied intimately with this is a delivery history – do the people you know and work with deliver on time, within budget, and more often than not surprise you with the good work they’ve done? If not, then it may be time to start looking for other people, and to build delivery clauses into your contracts!
To find good people, you need to know a few things:
Know exactly what you’re looking for
. Because the skills landscape has changed so much, it’s not easy to find highly skilled generalists – you’re more likely to find people with deep skills in particular technology stacks. The first question to ask is what platform you’re building your digital media on – is it Java, Microsoft .Net, LAMPPP (Linux, Apache, MySQL, PHP/Perl/Python) or are you looking to do some new Web 2.0 work where you’ll require people that are on the cutting edge. Are you looking for a graphic designer who knows the web, or are you looking for a web designer – they’re different! Are you looking to manage projects that are outsourced, or are you looking to manage projects internally. Either way, you’re only going to find the right people if you can answer the three questions above.
Know exactly what you’re prepared to pay for their skills and time
. Whether you’re looking to find an agency to help you, or bring in contractors, this will aid you in your negotiations and make finding the right person easier, just because most people with experience have minimum daily or project rates they’ll work for.
Know whether you’re looking for someone to help you on a part time / contract basis, or whether you’re looking for a permanent employee
. Again, in order to filter out potential applicants, make it clear what you’re looking for from the beginning. Every project has its own parameters, so make sure that you’re aware of yours and act accordingly – large projects with larger budgets inherently have more risk associated, so you’re probably going to want an agency that you can trust that risk with. In contract, smaller projects with smaller budgets probably can’t afford agency rates, so if that’s you, you’re going to need to find a contractor that will work within your budget.
If you know the above 3 points, then you should plumb your existing techie network to help you find good people
. Be they contractors or agencies, the best supplier referral is through a trusted contact, so if you can, try the people you know already before you try the yellow pages.
Know whom to trust with your projects
. It’s vitally important that you work with people that you trust. If you’ve not yet develop a trusting relationship with any kind of supplier then you’re better of offering smaller pieces of work first, to gauge delivery capabilities and work ethic, gradually growing the amount of work and corresponding budget you’re prepared to part with. Once you’re satisfied that your supplier can deliver and that their skills are up to par, and then consider a more formal arrangement where they’re contractually bound.
What we’ve discussed above is what we’re putting into practice when it comes to recruiting internally, so we hope that this is of some help. At the same time, we’re pretty sure that other people have had other experiences when it comes to finding good people, so we’d welcome any additional comments or feedback that you may have!
5 Comments
Denis Campbell
01 Jun 2006
Hello John,
I agree that choosing people is the most important decision any company can make.
The issue I have is most managers view this as a statistical rather than human enterprise/experience. Without knowing how to interact with people in what is admittedly the most contrived scenario man ever created - the job interview, they prefer small talk, over-talk/sell themselves, spend most of the interview talking and resort to picking apart a cv rather than building the rapport that leads to deeper revelations about who exactly that person is sitting across from you and... why.
The chairman of Sony before any big decision would dissolve a sugar pill in water and drink it and if at any time he woke up that night with indigestion or any other ailment, he would not touch the person or the deal with a 10 ft. pole. Trusting on gut feel is often more important than any word on a cv.
Key also is understanding that when someone is hired to do a task, they should be set up for success and I'm not just talking money. I always said to those whom I hired, "look, I'm busy, you're here to help me become more effective so please make sure I don't try to do your job as well as my own". Give them enough freedom and rope to both learn and soar on their own and know that it may end up differently (and much better because they 'own' their job) than you may have planned.
Too many times and in too many companies I see folks hired with " here's what I want you to do and here is exactly how I want you to do it." There is a fine line between supervision and control and the less of the latter one has, the less of the former is ever needed.
The first litmus test is the size of the rule book. The thicker the binder, the less trust exists. In a funtional organism or organisation, rules are unnecessary. In a dysfunctional organism or organization rules are unenforceable.
Thanks for the topic.
Wishing you well,
Denis Campbell
Denis Campbell
01 Jun 2006
Hello John,
I agree that choosing people is the most important decision any company can make.
The issue I have is most managers view this as a statistical rather than human enterprise/experience. Without knowing how to interact with people in what is admittedly the most contrived scenario man ever created - the job interview, they prefer small talk, over-talk/sell themselves, spend most of the interview talking and resort to picking apart a cv rather than building the rapport that leads to deeper revelations about who exactly that person is sitting across from you and... why.
The chairman of Sony before any big decision would dissolve a sugar pill in water and drink it and if at any time he woke up that night with indigestion or any other ailment, he would not touch the person or the deal with a 10 ft. pole. Trusting on gut feel is often more important than any word on a cv.
Key also is understanding that when someone is hired to do a task, they should be set up for success and I'm not just talking money. I always said to those whom I hired, "look, I'm busy, you're here to help me become more effective so please make sure I don't try to do your job as well as my own". Give them enough freedom and rope to both learn and soar on their own and know that it may end up differently (and much better because they 'own' their job) than you may have planned.
Too many times and in too many companies I see folks hired with " here's what I want you to do and here is exactly how I want you to do it." There is a fine line between supervision and control and the less of the latter one has, the less of the former is ever needed.
The first litmus test is the size of the rule book. The thicker the binder, the less trust exists. In a funtional organism or organisation, rules are unnecessary. In a dysfunctional organism or organization rules are unenforceable.
Thanks for the topic.
Wishing you well,
Denis Campbell
Jimbo Fisher
06 Jun 2006
Back in 99 ? Jesus that make me feel old...... I mean it was only 7 years ago....... try back in 69 .... now we're talking....
Jimbo Fisher
06 Jun 2006
Back in 99 ? Jesus that make me feel old...... I mean it was only 7 years ago....... try back in 69 .... now we're talking....
tomash
14 Jun 2006
hello Jimbo! Where can i download captcha tool for my blog?
Post a comment
Name
E-mail
Home page
Remember Me
Comment (Please don't use HTML)
Enter the code shown (prevents robots):
Lemon Newsletter
Stay in touch with all the latest from the fast-moving world of digital media.
Lemon News
Previous Posts
Developing Facebook Apps
Are we Agile enough?
What is an RSS reader?
Safari for Windows
Ruby on Rails
Why Facebook introduced widgets
Why online news sites are adopting social media
What’s behind the recent wave of display ad acquisitions?
Accessibility and web design
The joy and art of wireframing
What's the fuss about IE7?
Portable Firefox
Simpler is probably better
What’s happening on the Web today?
The times they are a changing…
The starter SEO checklist
The proverbial digital thorn in the side of every project
Making digital headway in 2006
Content Management doesn’t have to be hard…
Kool and the Web 2.0 gang
The trouble of recruiting good people
Ajax / web 2.0 – meaningless acronym or the NBT (next big thing)?
Is CSS really useful for clients?
Archive
February 2008 (2)
September 2007 (1)
July 2007 (2)
June 2007 (3)
May 2007 (1)
December 2006 (1)
November 2006 (2)
October 2006 (1)
September 2006 (2)
July 2006 (2)
June 2006 (3)
May 2006 (3)